Thursday, September 28, 2006

1300 Chapter 9 - Political Geography

Political Geography
  • The study of the organization and distribution of political phenomena in their areal expression.
Political Geography Considers (from Wikipedia)
  • How and why states are organized into regional groupings, both formally (e.g. the European Union) and informally (e.g. the Third World)
  • The relationship between states and former colonies, and how these are propagated over time through neo-colonialism
  • The relationship between a government and its people
  • The relationships between states including international trades and treaties
  • The functions, demarcations and policing of boundaries
  • How imagined geographies have political implications
  • The influence of political power on geographical space
  • The study of election results (election geography)

National Political Systems
  • State
    • An independent political unit occupying a defined territory and having full sovereign control over its internal and foreign affairs.
    • Does not include colonies or protectorates
    • Doe not actually include Anocracies – Iraq, Sudan, Afghanistan, etc…
  • Country
    • Same as state
  • Nation
    • A community of people with a common culture and territory, bound together by a strong sense of unity arising from shared beliefs and customs.
  • Nation-State
    • European invention
    • Where a nation corresponds to a state
  • Bi-national or Multinational State
    • States which contain more than one nation
    • Empires
  • Part-nation State (Irredentism)
    • A single nation predominant in and dispersed across two or more states
    • Greater Serbia or Greater Germany, Arab Nation
  • Stateless Nation
    • A people without a state
    • Amerindian Tribes, the Kurds, Basques, Palestinians

Anocracies (Center for Systemic Peace)
  • Societies where central authority is weak or nonexistent. Kinship bonds extended by personal allegiances to notable leaders are the principal relations. Likely to foster terrorism
  • A middling category of states with incoherent or inconsistent authority patterns: partly liberal, partly authoritarian.
  • Relatively vulnerable and volatile states that often lack effective institutions and/or the capacities to establish and maintain social order
Evolution of Modern States
  • Slow development of nations out of Empires and Kingdoms
    • China, Japan, Russia
  • Nation-States
    • European Development
    • People owe allegiance to the State instead of an individual
    • A state is comprised of a nation
    • Peace of Westphalia – 1648
    • Ended 30 Years’ War and the 80 Years’ War
      • Treaty of Münster
      • Treaty of Osnabrück
      • Treaty of the Pyrenees – 1659
      • Germany (Holy Roman Empire), Spain, France, Sweden, Holland
  • Colonial States
    • Generally Multinational States
    • Borders drawn by Colonial Powers
    • No concern given to extant nations already present
    • Drawn to according to political and military realities in Europe
    • Africa and the Middle East (Southwest Asia)
    • Colonial Legacies result in violence and economic uncertainty
Berlin Conference of 1884
  • 14 European states divided African up without regard to native status
  • Results of Superimposed Boundaries
    • African peoples and cultures were divided
    • Unified regions were broken apart
    • Hostile societies forced together
      • Minority Rule
    • Hinterlands disrupted
    • Migration routes closed
  • Legacy of Political and Economic Fragmentation
Colonial Legacy in Africa
  • Transportation grid is organized to move resources from the interior to the coast
  • Internal communication routes impeded
  • Dual Economy
    • States depend on just one or a very few crops or resources
    • Vulnerable to world markets
  • Antagonism between tribes within nations
Challenges to the State
  • Globalization
    • Transnational Corporations
  • International and Supranational Institutions
    • European Union
    • World Trade Organization
    • United Nations
    • NAFTA
  • Emergence of NGO’s
    • Interests and actions cut across national boundaries
  • International Migration
    • Dilution of national identities
  • Devolution
    • Nationalist and separatist movements

Geographic Characteristics of States
  • Size
    • Mini-states – states with very small land areas and, generally, less than one million people
    • Lichtenstein, Luxemburg, island states of the Pacific
  • Shape
    • Compact States
      • Roughly circular states
    • Prorupt States
      • Compact but with one or more narrow extension of territory
      • Myanmar, Thailand
    • Elongated States
      • Long and narrow states
      • Chile, Norway, Italy
      • Diversity of climate and peoples
    • Fragmented States
      • States with territory separated from the rest, as on islands
      • Indonesia, Philippines, United States
      • Issues of control and centralization
    • Enclave
      • Territory of one state is located within another state (form of fragmentation)
      • Angola, West Berlin
    • Perforated State
      • A state which surrounds an area which it does not rule
      • South Africa (Lesotho), Italy (Vatican City)
  • Location
    • Both Absolute and Relative
    • Northern Latitudes or Tropical
    • Landlocked States
    • Border States
Core Area
  • The original nucleus of the state, where the highest population density, largest cities, and most developed transportation networks exist
    • Paris Basin of France, Moscow in Russia
    • State’s capital is located

State Organization
  • Unitary States
    • States with highly centralized governments and strong national identities
    • Most Western and Central European States, Japan
  • Federal States
    • Associations of more-or-less equal provinces with a strong central government
    • United States, Canada, Australia
  • Asymmetric Federalism (Regional)
    • When a Unitary State recognizes the autonomy of regions within it and grants them some degree of local administrative control
    • United Kingdom (England, Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland)

Forward Capital
  • A capital positioned in actually or potentially contested territory
  • To confirm a state’s determination to maintain its presence in the region of contention
  • A “Growth Pole” Concept
    • A city founded to encourage regional economic development of the hinterland
  • Brasilia, St. Petersburg

Boundaries

International Boundaries

  • Lines that establish the limit of each state’s jurisdiction and authority
  • Where the sovereignty of one state ends and another begins
    • Surface rights
    • Mineral rights
    • Air space
    • Territorial waters and international waters
Frontier Zones
  • Ill-defined and fluctuating zones marking the edge of a state’s authority
  • Modern state boundaries generally eliminate frontier zones
Natural Boundaries
  • Based on recognizable physiographic features
    • Mountain chains
    • Rivers
    • Coastlines
  • Most of the boundaries in Europe
Artificial or Geometric Boundaries
  • A boundary without an obvious physical or geographic boundary
  • Often a parallel of latitude or meridian of longitude
  • Boundaries created by colonial powers in Africa and Southwest Asia
Antecedent Boundary
  • A boundary drawn before the landscape is populated and developed
    • The western boundary between the U.S. and Canada (49th Parallel)
    • 54-40 or fight…
Subsequent Boundary
  • Drawn after the development of the populated cultural landscape
  • Consequent (Ethnographic) Boundary
    • Drawn to accommodate existing linguistic, ethnic, etc., differences
    • Mason-Dixon Line
  • Superimposed Boundary
    • Forced upon existing cultural landscapes, a country, or a people by a conquering or colonizing power.
    • Africa and the United States
Relic Boundary
  • A former boundary line that no longer functions as such and is still marked by some landscape features on differences on the two sides
    • Berlin Wall
    • Hadrian’s Wall

Boundaries and Conflict

Landlocked States
  • Depend upon neighboring states for access to trade routes
Water as National Boundary
  • Along the centerline or the edge of a body of water
  • Along a watershed and ridge crest
  • Meandering rivers which change channels
  • Lakes
  • Use of that water
Minority and Group Identification
  • Irredentism
    • When an ethnic group in one country is more closely related to that in another.
    • Hungary-Romania-Transylvania or Germany and the Sudetenland
  • Stateless Peoples
    • Attempt to carve out a homeland from within one or more nations
    • Kurds, Basques
  • Internal Secessionist Movements
Resource Disputes
  • Immigration, Migration, and customs regulations
    • U.S. and Mexico
  • Resources which cross a border
    • Oil fields, water
  • Over land to protect a perceived resource
    • Israel – its own land

Centripetal Forces: State Cohesion

Nationalism
  • Personal identification with a state and acceptance of national goals
    • Adherence to laws
    • Acceptance of ideology
    • Participate in the process
  • Consensus Nationalism
    • Nationalism overcoming various group identities
    • United States, Switzerland
  • Iconography
    • The symbols which unite a people
    • Flags, songs, sports, etc…
Unifying Institutions
  • Both to identify with and to shape that identification
  • Schools and education
  • Armed Forces
  • Religion or churches
Organization and Administration
  • Public confidence in the effectiveness of the state
    • Protection from perceived enemies
    • Care of its people
    • Acceptance of the Rule of Law
Transportation and Communication
  • Ability to integrate far-flung pieces of the state
    • Roads
    • Railways
    • Phone and mail systems
  • Restrictions on international movement
    • Higher costs
    • Customs, Visas, and Border Checks

Centrifugal Forces: Challenges to State Authority (Devolution)

Religion
  • Multiple Faiths within a nation
  • Church as opposed to state authority
Sub-Nationalism
  • Where people give their loyalty to ethnic or “national” groups that are smaller than the State.
Regionalism
  • Identification with a small region as opposed to the State
  • Regional Autonomy/Devolution
    • The process whereby regions and peoples within a state demand and gain political strength and autonomy at the expense of the central government.

Terrorism and Separatist Movements

Factors behind the rise of Separatist Movements
  • Ethnic Cleansing
  • Government Oppression
  • National Identity and Territory
  • Peripheral Location
  • Social and Economic Inequalities

Terrorism (Fourth Generation Warfare)

  • Calculated violence to publicize a cause, intimidate or coerce a civilian population, or affect the conduct of a government.
    • Purpose to Create Fear
    • To achieve political or other goals without winning a military victory
    • Generally focus on “soft” or civilian targets
    • Symbolic targets
  • A weapon or a type of warfare or directed violence
  • Confusion over who is a terrorist
Types of Terrorism
  • International Terrorism
    • Acts which transcend state boundaries
  • Domestic Terrorism
    • Acts against their own country
  • State Terrorism
    • Acts committed by agents of a government
    • As old as states – Rome
  • Subnational Terrorism
    • Domestic Terrorism conducted by sub-national groups
Responses to Terrorism
  • Addressing the causes of the terrorist
  • Increasing international cooperation
  • Increasing domestic security
  • Military response

Supranationalism
  • Associations of three or more states created for mutual benefit where the states relinquish some national authority to the supranational organization.
    • United Nations
    • NAFTA
    • European Union
Untied Nations
  • Only universal supranational organization
  • Almost 200 members
  • Main focus is to promote world peace
    • Peacekeeping Forces
  • Member nations do not surrender sovereignty
Maritime Boundaries
  • Provide security for a nation
  • Control of trade and commerce
    • Customs Regulations
  • Enforce quarantines
  • Enforce claims of neutrality
UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) 1982 – Ratified 1994
  • Territorial Sea
    • 12 nautical miles
    • Exclusive sovereignty
    • Exclusive fishing rights
  • Contiguous Zone
    • 24 nautical miles
    • Limited sovereignty
    • Enforce customs, immigration, and sanitation laws
  • Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)
    • 200 nautical miles (350 within a continental shelf)
    • Exclusive rights to explore, exploit, conserve, and manage resources on the seabed and waters
  • High Seas
    • Beyond the EEZ
    • Outside any national jurisdiction (Freedom of the High Seas)
    • Right to access, use, and explore to all
    • Resources are considered part of the Common Heritage of Humanity
Regional Alliances
  • Smaller groupings of states for economic, military, or political cooperation
  • Formation of one coalition often stimulates formation of others
  • Usually formed from contiguous states
  • Internal Economies do not generally matter
Economic Alliances
  • European Union
    • Benelux Agreements
    • Organization for European Cooperation (1948)
    • European Coal and Steel Community (1952)
    • European Economic Community (EEC)/Common Market (1957)
      • Inner Six
    • European Free Trade Association (EFTA) (1960)
      • Outer Seven
    • Largest and richest of the world’s economic blocs
    • Single Currency
  • North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) 1994
    • Canada, United States, Mexico
    • Removing trade and movement restrictions between the states
  • Common Market of the Southern Cone (MERCOSUR)
    • Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, Paraguay, Venezuela
      • Associate members Bolivia and Chile
    • Free trade agreement
  • Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN)
    • Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Vietnam
    • ASEAN + Three
      • China, Japan, Republic of Korea
    • East Asia Summit
      • Plus Australia, India, New Zealand
  • Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Forum
    • 21 members
    • Free trade in the Pacific by 2020
  • Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC)
    • Control of oil production and distribution
    • Price controls
    • 11 member nations
    • Control around 66% of the world’s oil reserves
Military Alliances
  • Strength through unity
  • Depend upon common interests and perceptions
  • Depend upon political goodwill among the members
  • North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)
    • North America and Western Europe
    • Formed to protect Europe from the Soviet Union (Warsaw Pact)
    • Uncertain new mission
    • Focused on peacekeeping
Political Alliances
  • Based on a variety of different factors and concerns
    • Common objectives
    • Common history
  • Tend to be more loose than other alliances
  • Less loss of sovereignty than with other supranational organizations
  • Commonwealth of Nations
    • Formerly the British Commonwealth
    • 53 member states – all former British Colonies
    • Based on cultural commonalities
    • Focus on economic cooperation
    • Human rights and democracy
  • Organization of American States
    • 35 states of the Americas
    • Cuba is excluded
    • Earliest incarnations in the late 1800’s
    • Fully functional after 1948
    • Primarily focused on human rights and democracy
  • Failed Political Alliances
    • United Arab Republic
      • Syria and Egypt
    • Central Africa Federation
      • Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland
    • Federation of Malaysia and Singapore
    • Federation of the West Indies
Local and regional political organization
  • Have most effect upon individuals
  • Operate within well defined geographical areas
  • Make behavior-governing decisions
Geography of Representation
  • Redistricting/Reapportionment
    • Redrawing of boundary lines to reflect the most up-to-date population shifts
    • U.S. Census is most authoritative
      • Every 10 years
      • Basis for national congressional offices
      • Basis for many state and local offices
    • Most rely on state legislatures for redistricting
    • Gerrymandering
      • Drawing electoral districts so as to favor one political party over another
      • Tullymandering – Irish, generally refers to a failed attempt to gerrymander
  • Electoral Geography
    • Study of voting districts and the spatial patterns of election results
  • Political Fragmentation
    • Due to size of State and decentralized power
    • Reduction in efficiency
    • Duplication of effort
    • Competing and Conflicting ordinances and rules
    • Conflict between local and regional needs and interests
      • Pollution
      • Voting
      • Health Care
      • Zoning

No comments: