Friday, July 28, 2006

1303 Chapter 10 - Southeast Asia

Theory and Discussion of State development and Boundaries

Friedrich Ratzel

The Organic State

“The state is better understood as a 'natural' rather than a 'mechanical' phenomenon, with different institutions performing different functions, and the good health of the whole being attributable as much to the good working of the whole as to the contribution of any particular part.”

Major factor in the rise of environmental determinism.

Environmental Determinism
  • The belief that the physical environment by itself shapes humans, their actions, and their thoughts.
  • Central Geographic Paradigm up until the 1940’s
  • Humans operate under a stimulus-response relationship with the environment
  • Used to explain and maintain European/Western cultural and physical dominance
  • Ellen Churchill Semple – central U.S. proponent of this theory (early 1900’s)
  • Underlay the justifications used by the Nazi’s for their genocidal practices

National Geo-Political Systems
  • State
    • An independent political unit occupying a defined territory and having full sovereign control over its internal and foreign affairs.
    • Does not include colonies or protectorates
    • Doe not actually include Anocracies – Iraq, Sudan, Afghanistan, etc…
  • Country
    • Same as state
  • Nation
    • A community of people with a common culture and territory, bound together by a strong sense of unity arising from shared beliefs and customs.
  • Nation-State
    • European invention
    • Where a nation corresponds to a state
  • Bi-national or Multinational State
    • States which contain more than one nation
    • Empires
  • Part-nation State (Irredentism)
    • A single nation predominant in and dispersed across two or more states
    • Greater Serbia or Greater Germany, Arab Nation
  • Stateless Nation
    • A people without a state
    • Amerindian Tribes, the Kurds, Basques, Palestinians
Geographic Characteristics of States
  • Size
    • Mini-states – states with very small land areas and, generally, less than one million people
    • Lichtenstein, Luxemburg, island states of the Pacific
  • Shape
    • Compact States
      • Roughly circular states
      • Maximum amount of territory within a minimum length of boundary
    • Protruded/Prorupt States
      • Compact but with one or more narrow extension of territory
      • Myanmar, Thailand
    • Elongated States
      • Long and narrow states
      • Chile, Vietnam, Italy
      • Diversity of climate and peoples
    • Fragmented States
      • States with territory separated from the rest, as on islands
      • Indonesia, Philippines, United States
      • Issues of control and centralization
    • Enclave
      • Territory of one state is located within another state (form of fragmentation)
      • Angola, West Berlin
    • Perforated State
      • A state which surrounds an area which it does not rule
      • South Africa (Lesotho), Italy (Vatican City)
Boundaries
  • Contracts between States
  • Definition
    • Elaborate description of the boundary, usually in a treaty
  • Delimitation
    • The drawing of the border on a map
  • Demarcation
    • Physical boundary located on the ground at the delimitated border
International Boundaries
  • Lines that establish the limit of each state’s jurisdiction and authority
  • Where the sovereignty of one state ends and another begins
Frontier Zones
  • Ill-defined and fluctuating zones marking the edge of a state’s authority
  • Modern state boundaries generally eliminate frontier zones
Natural/Physiographic Boundaries
  • Based on recognizable physiographic features
    • Mountain chains
    • Rivers
    • Coastlines

Anthropo-geographic Boundaries

  • A boundary which coincides with breaks or transitions in the cultural landscape
    • Such as those formed between nations
    • European states
Artificial or Geometric Boundaries
  • A boundary without an obvious physical or geographic boundary
  • Often a parallel of latitude or meridian of longitude
  • Boundaries created by colonial powers in Africa and Southwest Asia

Genetic Boundary Classifications

Antecedent Boundary
  • A boundary drawn before the landscape is populated and developed
    • The western boundary between the U.S. and Canada (49th Parallel)
    • 54-40 or fight…
Subsequent Boundary
  • Drawn after the development of the populated cultural landscape
  • Consequent (Ethnographic) Boundary
    • Drawn to accommodate existing linguistic, ethnic, etc., differences
    • Mason-Dixon Line
    • Generally a long process of adjustment and modification
  • Superimposed Boundary
    • Forced upon existing cultural landscapes, a country, or a people by a conquering or colonizing power.
    • Africa and the United States
Relic Boundary
  • A former boundary line that no longer functions as such and is still marked by some landscape features on differences on the two sides
    • Berlin Wall
    • Hadrian’s Wall

Southeast Asia

Major Geographic Qualities
  • Fragmented Physiography of islands and peninsulas, dominated by high relief, tropical climates, tectonic plate intersections, earthquake and volcanic activity (Ring of Fire) – Krakatau and 2004 Tsunami
  • Fragmented Political Geography – quasi-Shatter Belt, increasing presence of Anocracy and instability
  • Population focused on Indonesia and the Philippines
  • Fragmented political, linguistic, religious, and cultural histories
  • Colonial legacies from Europe and Asia (mainly China)
Regions of the Realm - Mainland
  • Vietnam
    • Previously divided between north and south
  • Cambodia
    • Formerly French Indo-China
  • Laos
    • Formerly French Indo-China
  • Thailand
  • Myanmar
    • Formerly Burma
Geographic Qualities of the Mainland
  • Five states
  • Dominated by Buddhism
  • Multicultural and Multiethnic region
  • One of the least urbanized areas of the world
  • Multiple core areas

Vietnam
  • Population of 85.2 million
    • Population has doubled since 1975
    • 86.2% ethnic Vietnamese
    • 9.3% Buddhist
    • 80% no religious affiliation
  • Portion of French Indochina – 1887
    • Divided into three colonial districts
    • French Defeated in 1954
  • U.S. involvement in the 1960’s
    • Defeat of U.S. and South Vietnam in 1975
  • Elongated country
    • Bi-polar division between Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City (Saigon)
    • Both considered Core Areas
    • Ho Chi Minh City is the central market center of the state
  • Government similar to Chinese but maintaining more control over economy
  • Shift to a Socialist Market State

Cambodia
  • Classic Compact State
  • Population of 14 million
    • 90% Khmer
    • 5% Vietnamese
    • 95% Buddhist
  • Golden Age of the Angkor Empire (1000 – 1300 CE)
  • Portion of French Indochina – 1887
    • Independence in 1953
  • American involvement in 1970
    • Beginning of Civil War
  • Khmer Rouge Rule 1975 – 1978
    • Between one and two million people killed
    • Massive anti-urban, anti-intellectual campaign
    • Genocide
  • Vietnam invasion in 1978
  • Installation of democratic government in 1993
  • Capital of Phnom PenhClassic Primate City

Laos
  • Former French Indochina
    • Independence in 1949
  • Population of 6.5 million
    • 68% Lao Loum
    • 60% Buddhist
    • 19% Urbanized
  • Undeveloped
    • No railroads
    • Few good roads
    • Little industry
  • Interference by Western Powers
    • Drug Trade – The Golden Triangle
    • Resettlement and death for many of the hill peoples
    • Ethnic Cleansing?

Thailand
  • Formerly Siam
  • A Protruded/Prorupt state
  • Population of 65 million
    • 75% Thai
    • 14% ethnic Chinese
    • 94.6% Buddhist
    • 4.6% Muslim
      • Concentrated in the southern regions
  • The economy is stronger than all of the other mainland states combined
    • Strong workforce
    • Varied economy
  • Only SE Asian nation not controlled by colonial powers
  • Ethnic instability and unrest in the southern portions of the state
  • Capital of Bangkok is a classic Primate city
  • Overthrow of monarchy in 1932
  • Constitutional democracy until 2006
    • Military coup
  • Rising corruption
  • AIDS/HIV a growing crisis

Myanmar
  • Also known as Burma
  • A second Protruded State
  • Population of 47 million
    • 68% Burmese
    • Many other ethnicities present
    • 89% Buddhist
  • History of independent kingdoms
    • Finally conquered by the British in 1886
    • Front lines during WWII
    • Independence in 1948
    • Military coup in 1962
  • Rapacious and oppressive Military Junta
  • Poorest state in SE Asia and one of the poorest in the World
    • Despite rich agricultural lands
    • Newfound oil and gas reserves
  • Minorities oppressed and ignored by the ruling junta

Insular Southeast Asia
  • Sub-realm of islands and peninsulas
  • Fragmented political and cultural entities
  • Multi-cultural and multi-ethnic
  • Colonial legacy
  • Islam dominant

Malaysia

· A Fragmented State

· Population of 25 million

o 50% Malay

o 24% Chinese

o 7% Indian

o 11% other indigenous

o Population concentrated on the mainland

o No single dominant religion although Islam is strongest

· British Colony

o Independence in 1957

o Malaysia formed in 1963

o Secession of Singapore in 1965

o Conflict with Indonesia on Borneo

· Strong, growing, and diversified economy

o Mainland Malaysia is the industrial and technological center

o Malaysian Borneo rich in natural resources

Brunei

· Sultanate

o Defeated Spanish

o British Protectorate – maintained royal family in power

o Independence in 1984

· Population of almost 400,000

o 67% Malay

o 15% Chinese

o 6% Indigenous

o 67% Muslim

o 13% Buddhist

· Very similar to a Gulf State Sultanate

· Extensive oil and gas reserves

o Highest GDP in SE Asia

Singapore

· Independent City State

· Founded as a British trading port

· Population of 4.5 million

o 77% Chinese

o 14% Malay

o 8% Indian

o 43% Buddhist

o 15% Muslim

· Some of the highest population densities in the world

· Serves as an Entrepôt for much of SE Asia

· Economy focused on trade and high tech industries

· Parliamentary Democracy – Authoritarian tendencies

Indonesia

· World’s most expansive Archipelago (fragmented state – 1300 islands)

o Four major islands plus Papua

§ Java – Core Area

§ Sumatra

§ Kalimantan

§ Sulawesi

o Physiography dominated by volcanoes

· World’s fourth most populous state – 235 million

o 45% Javanese

o 14% Sundanese

o 7.5% Madurese

o 7.5% Malay

o 88% Muslim

o 8% Christian

· Largest Muslim nation in the world

· Former Dutch Colony

o Independence in 1945/1949

· Newly democratic

· Capital at Jakarta

Philippines

· Fragmented State – islands

o 7000+

o Three main groups

§ Luzon-Mindoro (north)

§ Visayan (central)

§ Mindanao (south)

· Population of 91 million

o 28% Tagalong

o Very ethnically diverse

o 81% Roman Catholic

§ 7% Other Christian

o 5% Muslim

· Former Spanish then American Colony

o Commonwealth in 1935

o Independence in 1946

· Capital of ManilaClassic Primate City

· Insurgencies

o Muslim in the South

o Communist in central and north

o Pirates

No comments: